Pipeline Insight: Epilepsy - Pipeline drugs struggle to outshine their marketed predecessors
Pages: 191
Publisher: Datamonitor
Date Published: October 2006
Format: PDF, Slide-Pack
Price: $11400
Overview
Introduction
Slow generic uptake, reformulations, follow-on products and new market entrants will ensure steady long-term growth of the epilepsy market despite several high profile patent expiries. UCB has emerged as the number one epilepsy company, and is set to strengthen their epilepsy pipeline if the proposed acquisition of Schwarz is confirmed.
Scope
*Analysis of patient potential, unmet needs and clinical trial design in epilepsy *Overview of drugs in pre-registration, Phase III, II and I; with analysis of key companies involved in the market *Detailed profiles of key compounds in development for use in epilepsy, with forecasts of drug revenues to 2015 *Discussion of UCB, Eisai, and GSK’s strategies and insight from key industry opinion leaders
Highlights
Following on from Keppra’s commercial success, UCB is the current epilepsy market leader. UCB’s existing relationship with neurologists will bode well for the potent follow-on compounds, brivaracetam and seletracetam.
UCB’s proposed acquisition of Schwarz will further boost its epilepsy pipeline and CNS marketing/sales capabilities. If the acquisition is completed, Datamonitor believes that UCB will continue to develop Schwarz’s Phase III pipeline product lacosamide.
Generic incursion in the epilepsy market is less profound than in other CNS sectors. Nevertheless, lifecycle management strategies will be necessary to maintain market share following patent expiries. For example, development of sustained release/extended release formulations such as GSK’s Lamictal XR can slow generic incursion.
Reasons to Purchase
*Understand unmet needs in the epilepsy market based on key opinion leader comments *Benchmark key late-stage epilepsy compounds against current market leaders *Assess the global (US, Japan, five major EU) sales forecasts of key late-stage pipeline drugs; and examine their clinical and commercial potential
Table of Contents
ABOUT DATAMONITOR HEALTHCARE
CHAPTER 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Scope of the analysis
Datamonitor insight into the epilepsy market
Summary
CHAPTER 2 PATIENT POTENTIAL
Definition of epilepsy
Etiology of epilepsy
Diagnosis of epilepsy
Epidemiology of epilepsy
Segmentation of epilepsy
Seizures are categorized according to their location of origin
Little difference in prevalence of partial and generalized epilepsy
Incidence of epilepsy peaks in early and late life
Unmet need in epilepsy
Unmet need 1: Efficacious treatments for refractory epilepsy
Unmet need 2: Reduction in adverse side effects
Unmet need 3: Greater treatment options for elderly patients
Unmet need 4: Greater treatment options for pediatric epilepsy
Unmet need 5: Compliance
Unmet need 6: Non-teratogenic treatments for use in pregnancy
Unmet need 7: AEDs which do not react with oral contraception
CHAPTER 3 R&D APPROACH
Classification of pipeline products
GABA modulators
Ion channel modulators
Glutamate modulators
Others
Clinical trial design in epilepsy
‘Add-on’ studies are the mainstay in clinical trial design
Clinical trial endpoints in epilepsy
Post-marketing studies are important for detecting rare adverse events
Key difficulties in epilepsy clinical trials
Heterogeneity of disease
Wide use of patients’ self-reporting
Applicability of trial results to the elderly population
Clinical trial design guidance from the EMEA
Current gold standard and comparator therapies
Gold standard epilepsy therapy unclear
Gold standard for partial epilepsy
Gold standard for generalized seizures
UCB’s Keppra is the comparator drug for new entrants
Numerous indication expansions in the last year
Comparison of responder rates for key pipeline, the comparator drug (Keppra) and other marketed AEDs in refractory partial epilepsy
CHAPTER 4 EPILEPSY PIPELINE ANALYSIS
Pipeline overview
Drugs in preregistration
Pipeline drugs in Phase III
Pipeline drugs in Phase II
Investigated epilepsy types for each key pipeline drug
Key companies involved in the epilepsy pipeline
UCB
Development of a drug with a novel mode of action and specific focus on epilepsy was a winning strategy for UCB
Keppra contributes over half of the revenue gained by UCB’s CNS franchise
UCB’s AED portfolio
Will UCB follow the same strategies in the future?
Eisai
Eisai’s CNS strategy is one of inlicensing AEDs
Overview of Eisai’s CNS franchise
Eisai’s AED portfolio
Strategies for success
Reformulations
Drug delivery methods
Chemical reformulations
Indication expansion
Drug versatility in the treatment of epilepsy
Targeting additional therapeutic indications
Bipolar disorder treatment is a lucrative market for anticonvulsants
Regulatory approval or off-label prescribing?
CHAPTER 5 GABAERGIC MODULATORS: LATE-STAGE DRUG ANALYSIS AND FORECASTS
Overview of GABAergic drugs
Pipeline summary
DP-VPA
Profile
Drug overview: currently in Phase II for severe forms of epilepsy
Clinical data
Clinical trial 1: Phase II trials of DP-VPA.
Clinical trial 2: Phase I clinical trial data were presented at the Fourth and Fifth Eilat conferences
Patient potential
Marketing factors
Satisfaction of unmet needs
Primary benefit would be in an improved side-effect profile
Forecasts to 2015
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
CHAPTER 6 ION CHANNEL MODULATORS: LATE-STAGE DRUG ANALYSIS AND FORECASTS
Overview of Ion channel modulator drugs
Pipeline summary
Rufinamide
Profile
Drug overview: currently in preregistration for LGS and adjunctive therapy for partial onset seizures
Clinical data
Clinical trial 1: The effect of the new antiepileptic drug rufinamide on cognitive functions
Clinical trial 2: Efficacy and safety of rufinamide adjunctive therapy in patients with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome.
Clinical trial 3: Rufinamide: a double-blind placebo-controlled proof of principle trial in patients with epilepsy
Clinical trial 4: Efficacy and safety of rufinamide as adjunctive therapy in adult patients with therapy-resistant partial-onset seizures
Preliminary data presented at the 8th Eilat Conference on New Antiepileptic Drugs
Patient potential
Potential in partial seizures is limited
Add-on rather than switching from other therapies
High potential for share of the Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome market
Marketing factors
Expansion outside the domestic market
Launch in an under-developed Japanese market
Increasing focus of epilepsy treatment
Launch of specialized CNS sales force
Off-label use following license in Lennox-Gastaut syndrome
Satisfaction of unmet needs
Additional treatment option for pediatric patients
Forecasts to 2015
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
Retigabine
Profile
Drug overview: potassium channel opener currently in Phase III development
Clinical data
Clinical trial 1: Phase II studies of retigabine in epilepsy.
Clinical trial 2: Multiple-dose, linear, dose-proportional pharmacokinetics or retigabine in healthy volunteers.
Phase II safety studies
Additional pharmacokinetic Phase I trials investigating drug interactions with retigabine
Ongoing clinical trials
Patient potential
Marketing factors
Valeant has some CNS sales and marketing experience, but a co-marketing deal will be required to realize retigabines revenue generating potential
Satisfaction of unmet needs
Adverse side-effects may be a concern
Similar efficacy for refractory patients as current drugs
Patient compliance may be an issue with a three-times a day treatment
No reported interactions with oral contraception
Forecasts to 2015
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
Lamictal XR
Profile
Drug overview: extended release formulation of currently available treatment
Clinical trial data
Ongoing clinical trials
NCT00113165: Study evaluating Lamictal extended-release therapy added to current seizure treatments in patients with partial seizures.
NCT00104416: Study evaluating Lamictal extended-release therapy added to current seizure treatments in patients with Primary Generalized Tonic-Clonic (PGTC) seizures
NCT00355082: Conversion to monotherapy with Lamictal extended-release tablets for treatment of partial epilepsy
Patient potential
Marketing factors
GSK has had varying success with this type of lifecycle management strategy in the past
Following initial high uptake, Paxil CR did not significantly help GSK maintain market share with Paxil
Successive launches of Wellbutrin reformulations has helped maintain market share following an initial slump
Will Lamical follow the Paxil or Wellbutrin model?
Satisfaction of unmet needs
Theoretically the side-effect profile may be improved over Lamictal IR
Patient compliance may not be increased due to once-a-day dosing regime
Forecasts to 2015
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
Late-stage products recently discontinued
CHAPTER 7 GLUTAMATE MODULATORS: LATE-STAGE ANALYSIS AND FORECASTS
Overview of glutamate modulator drugs
Pipeline summary
E-2007
Profile
Drug overview: AMPA glutamate receptor antagonist
NS-1209
Profile
Drug overview: AMPA glutamate receptor and metabotropic glutamate receptor antagonist
Ampanel (talampanel)
Profile
Drug overview: non-competitive AMPA receptor antagonist
Clinical data
Clinical trial 1: Clinical trial data presented at the seventh Eilat Conference on New Antiepileptic Drugs in Sardinia, Italy (May 2004).
Clinical trial 2: A crossover, add-on trial of talampanel in patients with refractory partial seizures.
Patient potential
Marketing factors
Satisfaction of unmet needs
No significant efficacy for complex partial seizures
Weak side-effect profile in Phase II study
Forecasts to 2015
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
Late-stage products recently discontinued
CHAPTER 8 OTHER LATE-STAGE PRODUCTS IN CLINICAL DEVELOPMENT
Overview of the other AEDs in late-stage development
Pipeline summary
Lacosamide
Profile
Drug overview: unknown mode of action
Clinical trial data
Clinical trial 1: Phase III trial for lacosamide in epilepsy.
Preliminary data from additional Phase III trials
Patient potential
Marketing factors
Co-marketing will increase uptake
Schwarz’s presence in the CNS market is increasing
Satisfaction of unmet needs
Reported efficacy in treating refractory partial epilepsy patients is encouraging
Unreported side-effect profile
Lack of teratogenicity in animal studies
Forecasts to 2015
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
Brivaracetam
Profile
Drug overview: orally active ligand of synaptic vesicle protein 2A (SV2A)
Clinical trial data
Clinical trial 1: Phase II study in Keppra refractory patients
Clinical trial 2: Smaller Phase II study investigating a higher dose of brivaracetam
Clinical trial 3: Phase IIb head-to-head with levetiracetam (Keppra)
Patient potential
Marketing potential
Commercial value of pursuing Unverricht-Lundborg disease indication
Can UCB bring both Keppra follow-on drugs to market at the same time?
Long patent life for brivaracetam and seletracetam could keep UCB as a leading company on the AED market for many years
UCB’s epilepsy franchise strategy
Forecasts to 2015
UCB’s epilepsy franchise will continue to grow throughout the forecast period if Schwarz’s pipeline AED lacosamide is incorporated into UCB’s portfolio
Datamonitor drug assessment summary
Seletracetam
Profile
Drug overview: high-affinity synaptic vesicle glycoprotein (SV2A)
UCB’s reformulation strategy differs between seletracetam and brivaracetam
YKP-509
Profile
Drug overview: unknown mechanism of action
Soretolide (D-2916)
Profile
Drug overview: unknown mechanism of action
Valrocemide (TVP-1901)
Profile
Drug overview: glycine derivative of valproic acid
CHAPTER 9 INNOVATIVE EARLY-STAGE PROJECTS
Key Phase I and preclinical antiepileptic compounds
Broad range of physiological targets being investigated in early-stage development
CGX-1007
Drug overview
Mechanism of action
Anticonvulsant potential
Alliances and collaborations
Datamonitor comment
Isovaleramide (NPS-1776)
Drug overview
Mechanism of action
Anticonvulsant potential
Alliances and collaborations
Datamonitor comment
Key research impacts on epilepsy
Genomics and proteomics might provide researchers with animal models mimicking refractory epilepsy
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Journal articles and conference abstracts
Websites
APPENDIX A
Forecast revenues
Competitive positioning analysis of pipeline epilepsy drugs
Contributing experts
APPENDIX B
Methodology
Definition of epilepsy market
Datamonitor forecast methodology
Product forecasts
Sales calculations
Definition of a standard unit
Japanese market data
Additional information
About Datamonitor
